The Social Risks for Co-operatives

Slide1As I have discussed, social media presents great opportunity for Co-operatives.  The International Co-operative Alliance has set forth an ambitious plan that “envisions co-operatives to be the fastest growing form of enterprise by 2020”.  It is likely that social media will be the harbinger of this message and is thus vital to the cause.  With great opportunity though, often comes great risks; namely, for co-operatives, in the form of compliance and regulatory risks.

Many co-operatives operate in industries, financial services, insurance, and even agriculture, that are heavily regulated.  I have discussed how credit unions, financial co-operatives, have been early adopters of social media.  They are thus the first co-operatives to deal with the risks.  It seems that many have found the risk too daunting to overcome.  A Financial Brand article found that “Credit unions on Twitter struggle to attract followers even after being active over two years, and 1 in 5 just give up entirely”.  The article found that “the vast majority of tweets sent are one-directional, often with links back to a press release or similar credit union web page.”  Such dry, safe content is indicative of an industry constrained by compliance and regulatory concerns.

There is hope for co-operatives, though, as according to Nichole Kelly in Social Media Explorer, compliance and regulatory risks can be managed.  PR risks, which fortunately co-operatives rarely face, are much harder to manage due to their unpredictable nature.  Compliance and regulatory risks are known; a credit union knows that it must take care in tweeting current loan rates, for example, as any inaccuracies would be published inaccuracies and thus open to fines and censure if incorrect.

Quitting Twitter and abandoning social media are not the answer to regulatory risk.  Creating a plan that includes active engagement and risk management is the solution. Suncoast Schools Federal Credit Union were recently caught over-thinking their social media strategy, likely due to fear over compliance and regulatory risk presented by Twitter.  After a year and a half of inactivity they jumped into Twitter to respond to an odd and unsavory tweet about one of their locations two days after it appeared.  The delay and their strange response turned into a PR risk once the Financial Brand picked it up for this article.

Co-operatives need to be active and engaged with social media if this decade is to see the growth the ICA predicts.  There is no need to shy away from engagement due to regulatory concerns, as these are risks that can be managed.


3 thoughts on “The Social Risks for Co-operatives

    • Thank you for sharing. This is vital research for credit unions.

      It’s not yet time to become Twitter Quitters, but it is time for CUs to stop believing that they are engaging with their membership when such a small percentage of their followers are actually members (or people for that matter).

  1. This is a very interesting post, Ian. I’m genuinely surprised at the statistics, specifically the 20% that “give up entirely.” The Suncoast Schools FCU example was also intriguing. I can understand the apprehension a co-op may have, based on the heavy regulation in their industries, however, with proper training as to what not to do, it should really open up the doors to what can and should be done. Looking at the Suncoast Schools FCU Facebook page, which was linked to in the Financial Brand article, the same apprehension doesn’t seem to appear there. There are numerous posts on their timeline, dating back to 2009, when they first joined FB. The posts include photos from local events and fundraisers, community issues, and financial information. I see no reason why they wouldn’t choose to link to some of this same information via the Twitter feed, or maybe split the postings between the two. This logic would go for any of the co-op industries facing similar issues. It seems like an easy fix to me, which is likely to be far more beneficial than abandoning the idea altogether, but I suppose I could just be oversimplifying things.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s